Can Existing Soil Protection Values Be Transferred to Industrial Hemp? An Exploratory Assessment of Economic Valuation Evidence
Débora Paulino
Abstract
Industrial hemp (Cannabis sativa L.) is increasingly discussed as a multifunctional agricultural crop with potential environmental benefits, yet economic evidence that can inform comparisons with alternative land uses remains limited. This study examines what existing economic valuation evidence can reveal about soil protection services potentially relevant to industrial hemp cultivation. An exploratory benefit-transfer approach was applied to valuation studies identified through the Environmental Valuation Reference Inventory using the terms “soil protection”, “soil conservation”, and “soil erosion”. Five studies met the predefined inclusion criteria, covering cost-benefit analysis, contingent valuation, willingness to accept compensation, and avoided-cost approaches in agricultural contexts in Ethiopia, India, Kenya, Spain, and Guatemala. The evidence was synthesised comparatively rather than combined into a single pooled estimate because the studies differ substantially in valuation concept, spatial scale, time horizon, currency, and decision context. An illustrative annual unit-value transfer was retained only for the study reporting directly comparable annual soil-related benefits; under the exploratory currency conversion used here, this corresponds to approximately €6–14 ha−1 year−1. This figure is not interpreted as the economic value of hemp’s soil protection. Instead, it is treated as a lower-bound reference value for a specific category of soil-related benefits. The analysis shows that existing evidence can provide useful reference points but is insufficient for hemp-specific valuation. Future research should combine biophysical evidence on hemp’s soil effects with primary economic valuation to establish context-specific values.
Review reports
Reviewer3 (AI review)
AI Review (reviewer3.com)
Comments (5)
1. Omitted monetary estimates and practices for Mishra and Rai (2014) — Minor
Information was extracted for each retained study on geographical context, environmental service, valuation method, value concept, spatial and temporal unit, and reported monetary estimate. Particular attention was given to the distinction between benefit
The methods section specifies that the reported monetary estimate and spatial and temporal units were extracted for each retained study. While numerical estimates are provided for the other four studies, the extraction for Mishra & Rai (2014) in the summary table and main text reports no numerical NPV, IRR, or BCR figures, currency units, or specific indigenous conservation practices, stating only that returns were positive over a 10-year horizon. This omission prevents readers from comparing the magnitude and variability of returns across the two cost-benefit studies. The authors should extract and report the actual numerical NPV, IRR, and BCR ranges and identify the specific conservation practices evaluated in Mishra & Rai (2014).
2. Search terms omit crop-specific and broader soil-health keywords — Major
Three search terms were used: “soil protection”, “soil conservation”, and “soil erosion”. Searches were conducted without initial restrictions on country, valuation method or publication year. The purpose of this broad search was to identify valuation evidence that
The authors conclude that there is an absence of primary economic valuation studies on industrial hemp's soil-protection effects and map this as a critical evidence gap. However, the search strategy queried only three generic terms—"soil protection", "soil conservation", and "soil erosion"—without conducting any targeted searches for "hemp" or "Cannabis sativa", and without searching for the broader soil indicators the authors later highlight as key hemp pathways, such as "soil organic matter" or "soil structure". A study that valued soil organic matter maintenance or rotational soil benefits of industrial hemp without using the exact phrases "soil protection", "soil conservation", or "soil erosion" would have been missed by design. To substantiate the claim that hemp-specific valuation studies are absent, the authors should either verify their search using crop-specific terms ("industrial hemp", "Cannabis sativa") and broader soil-indicator terms, or explicitly qualify the evidence gap as applying to the three searched terms within EVRI.
3. Unsubstantiated characterization of the transferred range as a lower bound — Major
This value should be interpreted narrowly. It does not represent the total economic value of soil protection, because the source study isolates only selected soil-related benefits. It 11 also does not represent the value generated by hemp. Rather, it is a lower-bound reference for a specific category of annual soil-related benefits in another agricultural context.
Throughout the manuscript, the converted €6–14 ha−1 year−1 range from Sain et al. (2017) is characterized as a lower-bound reference value for annual soil-related benefits. While the authors note that the source study isolates only selected soil-related benefits rather than total economic value, that only implies the estimate is partial for that specific Guatemalan site—not that €6–14 ha−1 year−1 represents a lower bound across agricultural contexts or for other categories of soil benefits, where marginal damages or benefits could also be smaller or zero depending on baseline erosion rates and off-site exposure (as shown by the negative returns on productive land in Balana et al. 2012). The authors should either provide empirical justification for why €6–14 ha−1 year−1 constitutes a lower bound or rephrase the characterization to describe it as a partial, context-specific reference estimate.
4. Unspecified biophysical service and practices in the source estimate — Major
The resulting €6–14 ha−1 year−1 range is therefore not interpreted as the economic value of industrial hemp, nor as a general value for soil protection. It is treated as an illustrative lower-bound reference for the particular soil-related benefits captured by the 6 source study. This conservative interpretation avoids combining values that represent
The illustrative unit-value transfer relies entirely on an annual soil-related benefit component of US$7–15 ha−1 year−1 from Sain et al. (2017), which the authors describe as representing a specific category of soil-related benefits. However, the manuscript never identifies what specific soil-related process or externality (e.g., nutrient retention, avoided soil replacement, water infiltration, or sediment reduction), what specific climate-smart agricultural practices, or what underlying valuation technique generated this US$7–15 ha−1 year−1 range in the Guatemalan study. Without defining the exact physical service and management practices being valued, readers cannot judge what the €6–14 ha−1 year−1 benchmark actually measures or how it relates to soil processes relevant to industrial hemp. The authors should explicitly state the specific soil indicators, agricultural practices, and externality pricing method behind the Sain et al. (2017) figure.
5. Missing search hit counts and screening attrition data — Major
could subsequently be screened for relevance to agricultural soil protection. Records returned by the searches were exported and examined for duplication and relevance. 2.3 Inclusion and exclusion criteria Studies were retained when they met three substantive criteria. First, the study had to concern an agricultural system or agroecosystem. Second, it had to apply an explicit economic
The authors state that records returned by the EVRI searches were exported, deduplicated, and screened against three inclusion criteria to yield five retained studies. However, the manuscript reports no quantitative search or screening metrics—such as the initial number of records retrieved per search term, the number of unique records remaining after duplicate removal, or the number of studies excluded at each screening criterion. Even for an exploratory evidence synthesis, omitting basic attrition numbers makes it impossible for readers to assess how selective the screening was or to reproduce the sample selection. The authors should add a breakdown or flow summary reporting the exact number of records retrieved, deduplicated, and excluded for each criterion.
xPeerd (AI review)
AI Review (xPeerd — DAReview)
Summary
This manuscript, titled Can Existing Soil Protection Values Be Transferred to Industrial Hemp? An Exploratory Assessment of Economic Valuation Evidence, addresses a relevant and underexplored question at the intersection of ecosystem-service valuation and industrial hemp policy. Its central strength is conceptual restraint: the author repeatedly avoids overclaiming and explicitly states that the retained valuation studies do not justify assigning a direct monetary value to hemp’s soil protection benefits. The paper also offers a clear organizing framework by distinguishing different value concepts such as long-term land-use returns, private opportunity costs, societal willingness to pay, and annual soil-related benefits . The methods are transparent in broad outline, and the conclusions are generally aligned with the evidence base, especially the statement that the €6–14 ha−1 year−1 figure is only an illustrative lower-bound reference rather than a hemp-specific value .
The main weakness is that the manuscript remains closer to a structured narrative evidence note than to a fully rigorous valuation study. The search strategy is narrow, the evidence base is very small, reproducibility is only partial, and the paper relies on an exploratory transfer logic without a defined target policy context. There are also presentation issues, including duplicated references and table-formatting defects in the extracted study summary, that weaken trust in editorial quality . I do not see clear signs of fabrication, but I do see some paper-quality issues that should be corrected before the work is treated as a robust review or policy-oriented valuation analysis.
Potential Major Revisions
- Clarify the manuscript’s epistemic status and contribution more sharply
The paper’s stated objective is modest and generally appropriate: “The objective of this study is consequently not to estimate a definitive monetary value for the soil-protection effects of industrial hemp” and instead to assess what economic valuation evidence might be useful as a reference for hemp-related decision-making . However, the manuscript still oscillates between being an exploratory scoping exercise, a benefit-transfer note, and a methodological caution paper. This ambiguity affects how the reader should evaluate novelty and evidentiary adequacy.
For example, the manuscript states that “The study contributes in two ways. First, it organises heterogeneous valuation evidence according to the economic perspective represented by each study... Second, it demonstrates both the usefulness and the limits of transferring such evidence to a crop for which hemp-specific economic valuation remains underdeveloped” . That is a reasonable contribution, but it is primarily classificatory and interpretive rather than inferential. I think the manuscript should explicitly identify itself as an exploratory scoping-style review with an illustrative transfer component, not as a valuation study in the stronger sense. That distinction matters because readers may otherwise overread the monetary output.
- Strengthen reproducibility of the search and screening process
The methods describe an “exploratory evidence-synthesis design followed by an illustrative benefit-transfer exercise” and state that valuation evidence was identified through EVRI using three search terms: “soil protection”, “soil conservation”, and “soil erosion” . The manuscript also admits that “the search was not intended to constitute an exhaustive systematic review of all literature on soil valuation” . That honesty is welcome, but the current description is not reproducible enough for readers to evaluate selection risk.
The paper should report:
- exact search date(s),
- total number of records retrieved per term,
- duplicate count,
- number excluded at title/abstract and full-text stages,
- full inclusion/exclusion logic in operational form,
- whether backward citation searching or supplementary database checks were performed.
At present, the text says: “After removal of duplicates across the searches and application of the screening criteria, five studies were retained for detailed analysis” . But without a transparent flow structure, the retained set may appear arbitrary. A PRISMA-style flow figure is not mandatory, but something close to it would materially improve methodological credibility.
- Define the target transfer context more concretely
A central methodological problem is acknowledged but not fully resolved. The paper notes that “the target question concerns industrial hemp cultivation without a single defined geographical policy site” and that this weakens transfer validity because “Environmental conditions, land prices, farming systems, income levels, institutional arrangements and conservation practices differ across these contexts” . This is a major issue.
If the manuscript is about transferability, then the target context cannot remain too abstract. Even an exploratory transfer exercise benefits from specifying at least one hypothetical decision setting: for example, Portuguese hemp, EU agri-environmental payment design, or crop-rotation comparison under Mediterranean conditions. Without such a target, the exercise becomes mainly conceptual. I think the manuscript should either:
- define a specific target policy geography and land-use decision context, or
- remove language that implies an operational transfer and frame the output strictly as a typology of potentially relevant value evidence.
- Justify more rigorously the use of the Sain et al. estimate as the sole annual reference
The paper states: “Only the annual soil-related benefit estimate reported by Sain et al. (2017) was used for an illustrative unit-value reference” because it was annual and per hectare in an agricultural context . It then converts “approximately US$7–15 ha−1 year−1” to “approximately €6–14 ha−1 year−1” using an “illustrative exchange rate of US$1 = €0.90” .
I think this step requires stronger justification because it is the one numeric output most likely to be cited by others. Even though the manuscript repeatedly warns against overinterpretation, the presence of a single clean range creates an anchoring effect. The author should:
- explain exactly how the “soil-related component” was isolated from Sain et al. (2017),
- report whether the original value is market, shadow-price, avoided-cost, or modeled social-benefit based,
- discuss why this study is more comparable to hemp than the others beyond unit compatibility,
- consider whether a common price-year adjustment is feasible,
- specify whether the conversion year is 2026 and why that is acceptable for illustration.
The manuscript already concedes that the conversion “is not presented as a formal price-year adjustment or as a statistically valid cross-country transfer” . That caveat is necessary but not sufficient; the selection logic for privileging this estimate should be much more explicit.
- Expand the discussion of the missing biophysical link
One of the strongest lines in the manuscript is that “the study also does not estimate the physical change in erosion, soil organic matter, soil structure or other soil indicators attributable to hemp. Without such a biophysical link, monetary transfer cannot establish the magnitude of hemp-specific ecosystem-service provision” . This is methodologically correct and very important.
However, this point should be elevated from limitation to central analytical framework. The manuscript would benefit from a clearer causal chain: hemp management → biophysical soil outcome → ecosystem-service flow → affected stakeholder welfare → valuation metric.
The paper gestures toward this logic when it states that “A defensible valuation requires evidence of how a management or land-use change alters an environmental condition, how that change affects the flow of ecosystem services, and how affected stakeholders value the resulting change” . I think this should be turned into a figure or a structured subsection, because it is the key reason the manuscript cannot support hemp-specific monetary conclusions.
- Discuss literature coverage risk and database dependence
The evidence base depends entirely on EVRI. The manuscript acknowledges this as a limitation: “Other relevant studies may therefore exist outside the database or may not have been retrieved using the selected terms” . This is a substantial limitation, especially because relevant studies may be indexed under terms such as land degradation, sediment retention, soil organic carbon, cover cropping, regenerative agriculture, erosion prevention, watershed protection, or agri-environment schemes rather than the exact three search terms used.
I think the author should either broaden the search or explicitly justify EVRI-only scope as a pilot mapping exercise. At present, the narrow retrieval strategy may have excluded conceptually relevant evidence, which weakens claims about what “existing evidence” can reveal.
- Improve anti-overclaim safeguards around policy relevance
The paper is careful in several places, especially where it says: “the present analysis does not provide sufficient evidence to recommend a hemp-specific payment rate” and “Policy instruments such as agri-environmental payments or payments for ecosystem services should be linked to measurable environmental outcomes rather than to the crop label alone” . This is a strong and responsible policy conclusion.
Still, because the title asks whether existing values can be transferred to hemp, some readers may expect a more affirmative answer than the manuscript ultimately supports. The conclusion that the paper “identifies a clear evidence gap” is probably the most defensible main finding . I think the title, abstract, and conclusion should be aligned even more tightly around that point, possibly by emphasizing “limits of transferability” or “evidence gap mapping” in the title or subtitle.
- Editorial-quality issues create avoidable credibility concerns
The references section appears to contain duplicated entries. For example, Amaducci et al. (2015), Balana et al. (2012), and Bateman et al. (2011) appear repeated in the references excerpt . In a paper centered on careful evidence interpretation, such duplication undermines confidence in document control.
The table extraction also shows formatting breakdowns, including split words and awkward line segmentation such as “Approxim ately,” “Willingnes s to accept,” and fragmented cells in the study-comparison table . Some of this may partly reflect PDF extraction, but if visible in the manuscript, it should be corrected because it interferes with readability and professionalism.
Potential Minor Revisions
- Typographic and formatting issues
The comparative study table appears to have several broken words and line-wrap artifacts, including:
- “Approxim ately” in the table entry for Nyongesa et al. and Rosario-Díaz et al.
- “opportunity-co st measure” in the interpretive note for Nyongesa et al.
- “externalitie s within climate-sm art agriculture” in the Sain et al. row
- “municipali ties” in the Rosario-Díaz row
If these are present in the submitted PDF rather than only extraction artifacts, they should be repaired.
- Reference-list duplication
The references include repeated listings, notably:
- Amaducci et al. (2015) repeated
- Balana et al. (2012) repeated
- Bateman et al. (2011) repeated
This should be cleaned carefully, and the full reference list should be checked for additional duplicates or omissions.
- Minor wording improvements for precision
The sentence “The missing link is a quantified biophysical relationship between hemp production and the specific soil-protection outcome being valued” is strong but could be made slightly more precise by referring to hemp management or cultivation system rather than “hemp production” broadly, since soil effects likely depend on rotation, tillage, residue management, and local conditions .
Similarly, the phrase “The main result is not a single monetary value for hemp” is accurate but could be sharpened by saying the manuscript does not identify a defensible transferable hemp-specific value under current evidence conditions .
- Structural refinement
Section 3 mixes descriptive synthesis with interpretive caution. A clearer internal structure could improve readability:
- characteristics of evidence,
- comparability barriers,
- implications for hemp valuation,
- policy implications,
- evidence gap and research agenda.
That structure would help separate “what the five studies found” from “what may or may not be inferred for hemp.”
- AI-content analysis
I do not see obvious signatures of low-quality generative text such as severe conceptual drift, fabricated terminology, abrupt shifts in register, or internally inconsistent argumentation. The prose is controlled, repetitive in a disciplined way, and methodologically cautious. If I had to estimate, I would assign a low-to-moderate probability that portions were AI-assisted at the drafting stage, roughly 20–35%, mainly because of the polished uniform sentence structure and repeated caveat framing. However, I do not see strong evidence of problematic AI-generated content, nor do I see epistemically harmful hallucinated claims within the manuscript itself. The much more concrete issue is editorial duplication in the references and some formatting defects, not AI misuse .
Assessed epistemic impact of possible AI assistance: low, provided the references, search protocol, and extracted value interpretations are manually verified. The manuscript’s core limitations arise from scope and evidence design, not from apparent machine-generated reasoning errors.
- Fraud / paper-mill screening
I do not see strong fraud markers such as impossible claims, nonsensical methodology, invented constructs, or aggressive result inflation. In fact, the manuscript is unusually cautious and openly states several important limits, including that the analysis “does not establish a causal or quantitative relationship between hemp cultivation and soil protection” . That reduces concern about fabrication. The main risk is not fraud but overinterpretation by future readers unless the manuscript’s exploratory nature is made even more explicit.
Recommendations
- Reframe the paper explicitly as an exploratory scoping review with an illustrative transfer example.
- Add a transparent search-flow summary with record counts, screening stages, and reasons for exclusion.
- Broaden or justify the literature search beyond EVRI-only dependence.
- Specify a concrete target geography or policy context for any transfer discussion, or otherwise remove quasi-operational transfer language.
- Provide a fuller justification for selecting Sain et al. (2017) as the sole annual reference and document the extraction of its soil-related component in more detail.
- Add a conceptual figure linking crop management, biophysical soil change, ecosystem-service flow, and welfare valuation.
- Tighten title and abstract wording so the main conclusion is unmistakably the identification of an evidence gap rather than a transferable hemp value.
- Correct duplicated references and inspect all tables for formatting integrity.
- If possible, include a brief appendix listing the five retained studies, exclusion logic, and any extracted variables used in the comparison matrix.
Overall, I judge the manuscript as coherent, cautious, and potentially useful, but not yet methodologically strong enough in its current form to serve as a robust valuation review or policy-facing transfer analysis. Its most credible contribution is not the €6–14 ha−1 year−1 figure itself, but the disciplined demonstration of why existing valuation evidence cannot yet sustain a hemp-specific monetary claim .
XSci (AI review)
Summary
The manuscript asks whether existing economic valuation evidence for soil protection can be transferred to industrial hemp. Using the Environmental Valuation Reference Inventory (EVRI) and three search terms — "soil protection", "soil conservation", "soil erosion" — the authors retain five studies from Ethiopia, India, Kenya, Spain and Guatemala, spanning cost-benefit analysis, contingent valuation and avoided-cost approaches. Rather than pooling these, they are compared qualitatively across environmental service, value concept, spatial and temporal scale and decision context, and classified into four economic perspectives (Section 3.5). One illustrative unit-value transfer is retained, from Sain et al. (2017): US$7–15 ha-1 yr-1 converted at US$1 = €0.90 to about €6–14 ha-1 yr-1. The authors conclude that the evidence cannot support a hemp-specific valuation and that primary work is needed.
Contribution and Significance
The manuscript's real contribution is a methodological refusal. In Sections 2.1, 2.4 and 2.5 the authors decline to compute a pooled mean, meta-regression or weighted average, on the correct ground that a net present value, a household willingness to pay and a farmer willingness to accept are not observations of a common parameter. Applied transfer exercises frequently do the opposite, and that restraint — including the refusal to attribute the €6–14 figure to hemp — is the most defensible thing in the paper.
Set against the closest prior work, however, the advance is small. The conceptual apparatus — that WTA is an opportunity cost rather than a benefit measure, that transfer validity depends on correspondence of service, population, scale and institutions — is already in Wilson and Hoehn (2006), Plummer (2009) and Richardson et al. (2015), all cited here, and the paper restates rather than extends it. Hemp itself contributes no evidence: no hemp study appears among the five, and hemp enters only in the framing of Sections 1, 3.6, 3.7 and 4. Relative to Kaur and Kander (2023), which already reviews hemp's environmental and economic sustainability, what is new is the observation that EVRI holds no hemp soil valuation — a narrow finding that Sections 2.3 and 3.8 concede the search design cannot establish.
Strengths
- The decision not to aggregate across value concepts (Sections 2.1, 2.4, 2.5) is correct and is argued explicitly rather than assumed.
- Section 3.3 reads the Nyongesa et al. (2016) willingness-to-accept estimates as the private opportunity cost of supplying the service: "a high willingness to accept does not mean that society receives an equally high environmental benefit" — a distinction often lost in applied payment-for-ecosystem-services work.
- Section 3.2 uses Balana et al. (2012) well: the contrast between a positive NPV of ETB 5,620 ha-1 on degrading marginal land and negative results on productive land shows that soil-protection value is inseparable from land opportunity cost.
- Section 3.7 draws the right policy inference — that agri-environmental payments should be tied to measured outcomes rather than to the crop label — and it follows from the analysis.
- The perspectives table in Section 3.5 is a compact, usable statement of what each value concept can and cannot support in a transfer.
Recommendation
Reject for Land (MDPI). Two of the standard grounds apply. First, the advance over prior work is too small: no hemp evidence is presented, and the methodological cautions restated here are already in the benefit-transfer literature the manuscript cites. Second, the central claim — that existing evidence is insufficient for hemp-specific valuation — is not supported, because a non-exhaustive search of one database with three terms and no reported record counts cannot establish absence. A redesigned paper with a documented multi-database search, and the illustrative transfer removed, could be publishable, but that is new work rather than revision.
Major Concerns
-
The conclusion of an evidence gap cannot be drawn from the search as described (Sections 2.2, 2.3, 3.8). The paper's headline finding is an absence, and absence claims depend entirely on search completeness. Yet no record counts are reported at any stage: how many records the three EVRI queries returned, how many remained after de-duplication, and how many were excluded for which criterion. There is no search date and no exclusion log, so five studies out of an unknown denominator cannot be reproduced. Section 2.3 acknowledges that the study "does not claim exhaustive coverage", which is candid but contradicts the conclusion built on it in Section 4. The choice of EVRI alone compounds this: EVRI indexes studies rather than standardised value estimates, whereas the Ecosystem Services Valuation Database (esvd.info) and its TEEB predecessor hold per-hectare-standardised estimates and were the natural second source here. Resolving this requires a documented search across at least EVRI, ESVD and a bibliographic database, with counts at each stage.
-
The €6–14 ha-1 yr-1 figure will not carry the weight placed on it (Abstract; Sections 2.5, 3.5, 3.7, 4). The conversion is arithmetically correct (US$7–15 × 0.90 = €6.3–13.5); the difficulty is what the number is then called. Section 2.5 presents it as illustrative and as an order of magnitude, then as "an illustrative lower-bound reference"; the Abstract calls it "a lower-bound reference value"; Section 3.7 calls it "an indicative benchmark". Lower-boundedness is a substantive claim and no argument is given for it — the authors would need to show that the soil-related benefits omitted by Sain et al. (2017) are non-negative and that the Guatemalan context does not understate the quantity relative to the unspecified target context. Neither is attempted. The exchange rate carries no date or source and no price year is fixed, so the figure is not a defensible order of magnitude for any stated year. Since the manuscript's own argument is that transfer is not valid here, the simplest resolution is to drop the figure from the Abstract and Conclusions and report Sain et al.'s estimate in its original currency and year.
-
The evidence table does not support the comparative analysis built on it (Section 3.1). Of five "reported values", the Mishra and Rai (2014) row contains no number at all ("Positive economic returns for the conservation practices examined over a 10-year horizon"), and the Balana et al. (2012) row gives ETB 5,620 ha-1 with no price year and no conversion, so it cannot be compared with anything else in the table. More seriously, the Nyongesa et al. (2016) row reports "Approximate US$90-220 acre-1 year-1", but that source reports willingness to accept per farm per year — roughly US$88 for grass strips to US$218 for fallowing — not per acre; average holdings there are about two acres, so the per-area figure would be near half what is tabulated. Please verify and correct the unit: the manuscript's stated contribution is precisely the careful separation of value concepts and spatial units.
-
The hemp question is posed but never engaged with evidence (Title; Sections 1, 3.6, 3.8). The title asks whether existing soil protection values can be transferred to industrial hemp, and the answer given is no — but the reasoning never passes through any hemp-specific material. Section 3.6 identifies the missing biophysical link and Section 3.8 states that no causal relationship between hemp cultivation and soil protection is established, yet neither reviews what hemp soil evidence exists. Recent field work should be assessed before the gap is declared, for example Jesmin, N. et al. 2025, "Evaluating the effects of industrial hemp cultivation on soil quality in Florida", Agrosystems, Geosciences & Environment. Without that, the paper cannot say whether the obstacle is missing economics, missing agronomy, or both — which is what its title promises to answer.
Minor Comments
- The reference list repeats Amaducci et al. (2015), Balana et al. (2012) and Bateman et al. (2011) three times each.
- Schluttenhofer and Yuan (2017) appears in the reference list but is never cited in the text.
- The evidence table in Section 3.1 is broken across two fragments, with the Sain et al. (2017) row split between them; the tables are also unnumbered.
- Section 3.8: "hem cultivation" should read "hemp cultivation".
- The willingness-to-accept values in Section 3.3 exceed the €6–14 reference by one to two orders of magnitude; the paper should confront this rather than leave both figures standing.
- Balana et al. (2012) concerns exclosures, whose benefit stream is largely woody biomass and which withdraw land from production; explain how this sits with the exclusion of forestry studies in Section 2.3.
- For the European valuation proposed in Section 3.6, Panagos, P., Standardi, G., Borrelli, P., Lugato, E., Montanarella, L. & Bosello, F. 2018, "Cost of agricultural productivity loss due to soil erosion in the European Union", Land Degradation & Development 29(3), 471–484, gives directly relevant per-hectare erosion costs and should be discussed.
- State the date the EVRI searches were run, whether the terms were exact phrases, and whether screening was done by one reviewer or more.
- The Abstract's "lower-bound reference value" should be brought into line with the hedged phrasing of Section 2.5.
- Section 3.5 states that the source study "isolates only selected soil-related benefits" — specify which components are included and which are not.
- Section 3.6 recommends identifying "the relevant soil-service outcome" for hemp; naming an indicator and a comparison crop would make this actionable.