XSci

Emergent Causality from Decoherence: A Hypothesis with a Defined Parameter, a Derived Regime, and an Explicit Conjecture

Lorca, Rafael Eduardo

Submitted by Lorca, Rafael Eduardo

Published October 26, 2026 · Version v1, October 26, 2026 · DOI 10.66977/xsci.2610.002v

Quantum Physics

Abstract

Emergent Causality from Decoherence: A Hypothesis with a Defined Parameter, a Derived Regime, and an Explicit Conjecture
An imaginary hypothesis, not a theory.
This is a revised version. It corrects errors from the previous version. It is still a hypothesis, not a theory. The weakest point is the premise that classical dynamics is causal. If that premise fails, the hypothesis fails.
________________________________________
Abstract
This manuscript proposes that classical causality is not fundamental but emergent, arising from the degree of decoherence of a system. We define a parameter for decoherence (purity), derive one regime (the classical regime) from it, confront the established literature, and acknowledge the limits of the proposal. We add an explicit conjecture connecting the parameter to the process-matrix formalism of Oreshkov, Costa and Brukner. The hypothesis is not a theory. It lacks full mathematics, experimental confirmation, and a resolution of the circularity of time. It is offered as a framework for critique and development.
________________________________________
1. Introduction
The nature of causality remains an open problem in physics. In quantum mechanics, there is no causal structure in the classical sense: there are correlations, not causes. In classical physics, causality is absolute and local. These descriptions do not obviously fit together.
This manuscript proposes that classical causality is not a fundamental property of the universe, but a property of the level of description. It emerges from the degree of decoherence of a system, in a manner analogous to how temperature emerges from the collective behaviour of many particles.
The hypothesis is labelled "imaginary" because it lacks full mathematical formalism, experimental confirmation, and a resolution of the circularity of time. It is offered as a framework for critique, not as a completed theory.
Scope: This hypothesis addresses only the transition between the quantum regime (no defined causal order) and the classical regime (defined causal order). It does not address the relativistic regime.
________________________________________
2. The Parameter
The central parameter is the degree of decoherence, γ. In standard treatments, decoherence is not a single scalar: it is a basis-dependent, model-dependent process characterised by decoherence rates, a pointer basis, and a system-environment split. Different measures (purity, coherence norms, entanglement with the environment, predictability sieve) order states differently.
For the purposes of this hypothesis, we choose a specific measure: purity, defined as:
P = Tr(ρ²)
where ρ is the reduced density matrix of the system. For a pure state, P = 1. For a maximally mixed state, P = 1/d, where d is the dimension of the Hilbert space. We define the degree of decoherence as:
γ = 1 - P
Thus, γ = 0 for a pure state (no decoherence), and γ > 0 for a mixed state (decoherence).
This is a choice. Other measures are possible. This choice is made for definiteness, not because it is uniquely correct. The hypothesis does not depend on this specific choice; it depends on the existence of some measure that orders states by their degree of decoherence. Purity is chosen as a concrete example.
________________________________________
3. The Derivation (Weak)
With this parameter, we can derive one regime: the classical regime. We postulate that classical causality emerges when γ exceeds a critical value, γ_c. Below γ_c, the system is in a quantum regime: correlations without definite causal order. Above γ_c, the system is in a classical regime: cause and effect, without ambiguity.
This is not a derivation from first principles. It is a postulate. But it is a postulate with a defined parameter. And it is a starting point.
The intermediate regime is not derived. It is postulated as a transition. And it is acknowledged that this placement is in tension with established physics: relativistic causal structure is a property of the spacetime metric, not of partial decoherence. This hypothesis does not address the relativistic regime. It addresses only the transition between the quantum regime (no defined causal order) and the classical regime (defined causal order).
________________________________________
4. Confrontation with the Literature
The hypothesis must be placed against the established literature on decoherence and emergent causality. The following works are directly relevant. We do not confront them as attacks, nor do we attempt to surpass them. We use them as anchors: we situate the hypothesis relative to them, and we state explicitly what is already done and what is added here.
• Zurek (2003), "Decoherence, einselection, and the quantum origins of the classical," Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 715. This is the foundational account of classical structure emerging from environmental monitoring. Zurek shows that decoherence selects a small set of stable states (pointer states) and that the combination of einselection with dynamics leads to the emergence of classical phase-space structure: points, trajectories, classical dynamics. This hypothesis assumes, as an additional premise, that classical dynamics is causal. This premise is not derived from Zurek or from Gell-Mann and Hartle. It is an independent claim, and it is the weakest point in the argumentative chain. If the premise is true, then causality emerges from decoherence. If it is false, the hypothesis fails. It is offered as a conjecture, not as a derivation.
• Gell-Mann and Hartle (1994, 2014), "Quasiclassical Realms in a Quantum Universe" (gr-qc/9404017) and "Adaptive Coarse Graining, Environment, Strong Decoherence, and Quasiclassical Realms" (arXiv:1312.7454). These works derive classical deterministic time-correlations and the fixed-past/open-future asymmetry from coarse-graining and strong decoherence, with no observer. The present hypothesis is close to this programme. It differs in framing the result as "emergent causality" rather than "quasiclassical realms." The substance is similar. The present hypothesis does not resolve the circularity of time; it assumes time as a parameter of unitary evolution.
• Oreshkov, Costa, and Brukner (2012), "Quantum correlations with no causal order," Nature Communications 3, 1092. DOI: 10.1038/ncomms2076. This work constructs correlations with no definite causal order and shows that definite order is recovered in a classical limit. The present hypothesis is consistent with this, but does not engage with the formalism. A conjecture connecting the two is offered in Section 5.
• Page and Wootters (1983), "Evolution without evolution: Dynamics described by stationary observables," Phys. Rev. D 27, 2885. This work obtains time from entanglement with an internal clock. The present hypothesis does not address this. It assumes time as a parameter. The relationship between the two proposals is not resolved here.
• Joos and Zeh (1985), "The emergence of classical properties through interaction with the environment," Z. Phys. B 59, 223. Foundational work on decoherence in open quantum systems. The present hypothesis builds on this without adding to it.
• Rovelli (1996), "Relational quantum mechanics," Int. J. Theor. Phys. 35, 1637. Relational quantum mechanics holds that states are relational, not absolute. The present hypothesis extends this to causality: if states are relational, perhaps causal structure is too. But the extension is not derived. It is proposed.
• Schlosshauer (2005), "Decoherence, the measurement problem, and interpretations of quantum mechanics," Rev. Mod. Phys. 76, 1267. A review of decoherence and its interpretational implications. The present hypothesis assumes this framework.
The honest assessment: The hypothesis is not new in its intuition. It is new in its emphasis on causality as the emergent property, and in its attempt to frame the quantum-classical transition as a causal transition. But the emphasis is not a theory, and the transition is not derived. The hypothesis is offered as a framework for critique.
________________________________________
5. Conjecture: Connection with the Process-Matrix Formalism
The conjecture that follows is supported by the premise of Section 4. If classical dynamics is causal, then the transition from γ = 0 to γ > γ_c could correspond to the transition from a causally non-separable process matrix to a causally separable one.
Oreshkov, Costa and Brukner (2012) have shown that, if one does not assume a global causal order, there exist quantum correlations that violate the causal inequality. These correlations are described by process matrices that are causally non-separable. In a classical limit, causal order emerges. The authors suggest that spacetime could emerge from a more fundamental structure in a quantum-to-classical transition.
This hypothesis proposes, as a conjecture, that the more fundamental structure could be decoherence, parametrised by γ. The causally non-separable process matrix could correspond to γ = 0 (no decoherence, no defined causal order). The causally separable process matrix could correspond to γ > γ_c (sufficient decoherence, emergent causal order). The quantum-to-classical transition mentioned by Oreshkov et al. could be the transition in γ.
This is a conjecture. It is not derived. There is no formalism that supports it. It is offered as a direction for future work: if someone with the appropriate mathematical tools wishes to attempt the connection, here is the intuition. And here is the criterion for success: if the connection is derived, the hypothesis gains. If it is not, it loses. Both outcomes are valuable.
________________________________________
6. The Limits
The hypothesis has several limits, acknowledged here:
1. The parameter is chosen, not derived. Purity is one measure among many. Other measures would give different results. The choice is made for definiteness, not because it is uniquely correct.
2. Only one regime is derived (weakly). The classical regime is postulated, not derived from first principles. The relativistic regime is not addressed.
3. The circularity of time is not resolved. Decoherence presupposes time. The arrow of time is traced to a low-entropy initial condition, not to decoherence itself. The hypothesis does not resolve this circularity. It assumes it.
4. The literature is confronted, but not surpassed. The hypothesis shares its intuition with Zurek, Gell-Mann and Hartle, and others. It does not add formalism. It adds a framing, but the framing is not a derivation.
5. No experimental prediction is made. The hypothesis does not identify a falsifiable consequence. This is a significant weakness.
6. The conjecture is not derived. The connection with the process-matrix formalism is offered as a conjecture, not as a result.
7. The weakest point is the premise that classical dynamics is causal. This premise is not derived. It is an independent claim. If it fails, the hypothesis fails.
________________________________________
7. Conclusion
This manuscript proposes that classical causality is not fundamental but emergent, arising from the degree of decoherence of a system. It defines a parameter (purity), derives one regime (classical, weakly), confronts the established literature, acknowledges its limits, and offers an explicit conjecture connecting the parameter to the process-matrix formalism.
It is not a theory. It is a hypothesis. It is offered as a framework for critique and development.
The next steps would be: to derive the classical regime from the parameter more rigorously; to resolve the circularity of time; to identify a falsifiable prediction; and to engage with the formalism of Oreshkov et al. These steps are not taken here. They are left for future work.
________________________________________
The label (important)
This is an imaginary hypothesis, not a theory. It is coherent with what we know, but it is not demonstrated. It lacks full mathematics, predictions, and confirmation. It does not say that time does not exist. It says that classical causality could emerge. It does not say that the relativistic regime is explained. It says that the quantum-classical transition could be a causal transition. All of this, if one takes decoherence seriously, without adding anything else. But no one has demonstrated it. That is why it is a hypothesis, not a theory. And the weakest point is the premise that classical dynamics is causal. If that premise fails, the hypothesis fails.
________________________________________
A note on the anchor
This hypothesis does not invent its premise. It takes it from established physics: quantum mechanics already treats information as correlation, not as substance. Entanglement is pure correlation. Decoherence is entanglement with the environment. If information is always relational, then causality could be relational too. But the extension is not derived. It is proposed.
________________________________________
Related work (with authors, years, and identifiers)
• Zurek, W. H. (2003). "Decoherence, einselection, and the quantum origins of the classical." Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 715.
• Gell-Mann, M., and Hartle, J. B. (1994). "Quasiclassical Realms in a Quantum Universe." gr-qc/9404017.
• Gell-Mann, M., and Hartle, J. B. (2014). "Adaptive Coarse Graining, Environment, Strong Decoherence, and Quasiclassical Realms." arXiv:1312.7454.
• Page, D. N., and Wootters, W. K. (1983). "Evolution without evolution: Dynamics described by stationary observables." Phys. Rev. D 27, 2885.
• Oreshkov, O., Costa, F., and Brukner, Č. (2012). "Quantum correlations with no causal order." Nature Communications 3, 1092. DOI: 10.1038/ncomms2076.
• Joos, E., and Zeh, H. D. (1985). "The emergence of classical properties through interaction with the environment." Z. Phys. B 59, 223.
• Rovelli, C. (1996). "Relational quantum mechanics." Int. J. Theor. Phys. 35, 1637.
• Schlosshauer, M. (2005). "Decoherence, the measurement problem, and interpretations of quantum mechanics." Rev. Mod. Phys. 76, 1267.

View PDF

Review reports

XSci (AI review)

October 26, 2026

Summary

The manuscript proposes that classical causality is not fundamental but emerges from the degree of decoherence of a system, as temperature emerges from many-particle behaviour. It defines a decoherence parameter as one minus the purity of the reduced density matrix (Sec. 2), and postulates that a definite causal order obtains above a critical value of that parameter and fails below it (Sec. 3). Section 4 situates the proposal against Zurek (2003), Gell-Mann and Hartle, Oreshkov, Costa and Brukner (2012), Page and Wootters (1983) and Rovelli (1996). Section 5 conjectures that the causally non-separable process matrix corresponds to zero decoherence and the causally separable one to decoherence above threshold; Section 6 lists seven acknowledged limits.

Contribution and Significance

The intended contribution is a reframing: that the quantum-to-classical transition should be understood specifically as a transition in causal structure, indexed by a single scalar. The authors state this themselves in Sec. 4 — "The hypothesis is not new in its intuition. It is new in its emphasis on causality as the emergent property" — and I agree with that assessment of what is on offer.

Measured against the closest prior work, the reframing does not amount to an advance. Gell-Mann and Hartle (arXiv:1312.7454) already derive classical deterministic time-correlations and the fixed-past/open-future asymmetry from coarse-graining and strong decoherence with no observer; the manuscript concedes at Sec. 4 that "The substance is similar." Zurek (2003) derives classical trajectories from einselection, and Oreshkov et al. (2012) identify a classical limit in which definite causal order is recovered. What would distinguish the present proposal is a map from a decoherence quantity to causal (non-)separability — and Sec. 5 states plainly that "There is no formalism that supports it." Each of the title's three claims is withdrawn in the body: the parameter is declared non-essential at Sec. 2, the derivation a postulate at Sec. 3, the conjecture unsupported at Sec. 5.

Strengths

  • Section 6 is an unusually candid, itemised account of seven limits, including the absence of any falsifiable consequence (Limit 5) and the correct observation that the arrow of time traces to a low-entropy initial condition rather than to decoherence (Limit 3).
  • Section 4 identifies the right anchors for the question posed and states, work by work, what the proposal does and does not add, rather than overstating its position.
  • Section 5 names a concrete formal target and a success criterion: "if the connection is derived, the hypothesis gains. If it is not, it loses."

Recommendation

Reject for Foundations of Physics. Two of the standard grounds apply together. First, the advance over the named prior work is too small and too unclear to matter: the manuscript's own comparison with Gell-Mann and Hartle concedes substantive overlap, and what remains is a change of emphasis with no formalism attached. Second, the central claims are not supported and cannot be supported within the manuscript's approach, because that approach contains no derivation; where the manuscript is technically specific, in Secs. 2 and 5, it is demonstrably wrong. Foundations of Physics does publish conceptual papers, but they carry an argument or a worked analysis.

Major Concerns

  1. Nothing is derived, and the key term is never defined (Title; Abstract; Secs. 3 and 4; Limits 2 and 5). The abstract states that the authors "derive one regime (the classical regime)," and the title announces "a Derived Regime." Section 3 then states: "This is not a derivation from first principles. It is a postulate," and Limit 2 repeats it. Section 3 contains no mathematical step: it names a critical value and asserts a regime on either side, and Limit 5 adds that no falsifiable consequence is identified. The load-bearing step is the premise at Sec. 4 that "classical dynamics is causal," which the authors correctly flag as the weakest link; supplying that argument is exactly what would be needed to say anything Zurek and Gell-Mann and Hartle do not already say.

    The premise cannot even be evaluated as written, because "causal" is never defined. The manuscript uses "causality," "causal order," "cause and effect" and "causal structure" interchangeably, and these are distinct notions: deterministic time-evolution, definite causal order in the process-matrix sense, and interventionist causation in the sense of Allen, Barrett, Horsman, Lee and Spekkens, "Quantum Common Causes and Quantum Causal Models," Phys. Rev. X 7, 031021 (2017). The whole content of the proposal lies in whether the first entails the second. Fixing a definition and attempting that entailment, for even one toy model, is the minimum that would turn this into a paper.

  2. The chosen parameter cannot do the work assigned to it (Secs. 2 and 3). Three defects follow from the definitions given. First, it is dimension-dependent: since the maximally mixed state has purity 1/d, the parameter ranges over zero to 1 − 1/d, reaching at most 1/2 for a qubit and tending to 1 for a macroscopic system. A single critical value therefore cannot classify systems of different dimension, and the manuscript nowhere makes the threshold dimension-relative. Second, purity is basis-independent, whereas decoherence — as Sec. 2 itself states — is basis-dependent and defined relative to a pointer basis; purity cannot distinguish a state decohered in the pointer basis from one mixed in any other basis, nor from a thermal state. A single qubit at high temperature has a parameter value near 1/2 and would, by Sec. 3, sit in "a classical regime: cause and effect, without ambiguity." Third, the reduced density matrix presupposes a system–environment cut that is never specified; global purity is constant under unitary evolution, so the same physics yields any value in the range depending on where one cuts.

    The reply at Sec. 2 — that "The hypothesis does not depend on this specific choice; it depends on the existence of some measure that orders states by their degree of decoherence" — does not rescue the position, because Sec. 2 has already conceded that "Different measures ... order states differently." If the ordering is measure-dependent, there is no fact of the matter about which side of the threshold a state falls on, and the claim to have supplied a defined parameter is empty.

  3. The Section 5 conjecture is contradicted by established results in the formalism it invokes (Sec. 5). The conjecture proposes that "The causally non-separable process matrix could correspond to γ = 0 (no decoherence, no defined causal order)," and the causally separable one to a parameter value above threshold. Both directions fail. Zero decoherence does not imply indefinite causal order: every ordinary experiment performed on a pure state has zero parameter value and a perfectly definite causal order, which alone refutes the correspondence. Nonzero decoherence does not imply causal separability: the causal non-separability of the quantum switch is robust to noise, and under dephasing on the control qubit it survives at any nonzero visibility — see Araújo, Branciard, Costa, Feix, Giarmatzi and Brukner, "Witnessing causal nonseparability," New J. Phys. 17, 102001 (2015), and Branciard, "Witnesses of causal nonseparability: an introduction and a few case studies," Sci. Rep. 6, 26018 (2016). There is also a type mismatch: causal (non-)separability is a property of a process matrix, the parameter a property of a state, and no map between them is offered. The authors should engage with Castro-Ruiz, Giacomini and Brukner, "Dynamics of Quantum Causal Structures," Phys. Rev. X 8, 011047 (2018), which studies the transition conjectured here and shows that continuous reversible dynamics cannot carry a definite causal structure into an indefinite one.

Minor Comments

  1. The preprint gr-qc/9404017, "Quasiclassical Realms in a Quantum Universe," is single-authored by J. B. Hartle, not by Gell-Mann and Hartle as given in Sec. 4 and in the reference list; the 2014 entry (arXiv:1312.7454) is correctly attributed.
  2. The displayed equations in Sec. 2 read "P = Tr(p²)" and "y = 1 − p", the second of which mixes the symbol for the density matrix with that for purity, and Sec. 5 twice writes "γ_{-c}" for the critical value.
  3. The sections "The label (important)" and "A note on the anchor" restate Secs. 1 and 6 without adding content and should be absorbed into them, and the opening line "This is a revised version. It corrects errors from the previous version" belongs in a cover letter.
  4. Section 4 extends Rovelli (1996) to causal structure but states "the extension is not derived. It is proposed" — the relational reading of causal order is the most promising thread here and deserves development.
  5. Page and Wootters (1983) is set aside with "The relationship between the two proposals is not resolved here," which is where Limit 3 on the circularity of time could have been addressed.
  6. Name one candidate observable: a system in which the proposed threshold could be crossed, and the measurement that would distinguish the two regimes.
  7. Relatedly, estimate the critical value for one concrete model — a dephasing qubit, or a Caldeira-Leggett oscillator — and show that it is not simply set by hand.
  8. If the parameter is retained, compare it against the established quantifiers of indefinite causal order, causal witnesses and causal robustness, and say what a purity-based quantity adds to them.

Author response

I thank the reviewer for a detailed and constructive report. I accept the main criticisms.

1. The title says "Derived Regime", but Section 3 says "postulate". This is a contradiction. The correction is to change the title to "A Postulated Regime" or "A Proposed Regime". I will do this in the next version.

2. "Causal" is not defined. The reviewer is correct: without a definition, the premise "classical dynamics is causal" cannot be evaluated. The reference to Allen, Barrett, Horsman, Lee and Spekkens (2017) is exactly what I need to define it. I will include it in the next version.

3. The parameter (purity) cannot do the work assigned to it. The three defects (dimension-dependence, basis-independence, system-environment cut) are real. The next version will need a parameter that does not depend on dimension, or an explicit treatment of the cut.

4. The Section 5 conjecture is contradicted by established results. The reviewer is correct: Araújo et al. (2015) and Branciard (2016) show that zero decoherence does not imply indefinite causal order, and that the causal non-separability of the quantum switch is robust to noise. The conjecture, as stated, does not hold.

This manuscript is a hypothesis, not a theory. The reviewer has made this clear. And I accept it. With more time, the next version will define "causal", choose a parameter that works, and confront the formalism of Oreshkov with the references the reviewer has provided.

Thank you for the map.