Expert peer review for research manuscripts
One independent expert in your field reads your manuscript in depth and judges whether, after revision of the kind journals normally ask for, it has the potential to be published in the journals you are aiming at. You receive a written report whatever the decision.
What is expert peer review on XSci?
An independent assessment of your manuscript by a researcher with relevant expertise, against a published standard. You name up to three target journals, or leave it blank for the top journals of your field.
- Human judgement. A qualified researcher makes the assessment, not an automated score.
- A published standard. The review follows the Certification Standard, which anyone can read.
- Written reasons. You receive the findings, the concerns and the reasons for the decision.
- Independent verdict. The reviewer is paid the same whatever they decide.
Two ways to request it
| Published as a preprint | Without publishing | |
|---|---|---|
| Manuscript | Posted on XSci, with a DOI | Not posted, no DOI |
| Assessment | The same: one expert, the same nine areas, the same standard | |
| Certification | If the standard is met, it becomes an XSci Peer-Certified Preprint | Not conferred; the assessment is recorded and given to you |
| Report | Public or private, your choice | Private |
If you later post a version the assessment found meets the standard, it becomes a certification at that point.
How expert peer review works
- Upload your manuscript. Publish it as a preprint, or choose to analyse it without publishing.
- Select Human Review and name your targets. Up to three journals, or blank for the top journals of your field.
- An expert assesses it. Invited from the authors you cite, their close collaborators, or researchers who publish in your target journals.
- Receive your report. Written findings and a decision. You can submit one response.
What does an expert reviewer evaluate?
A finding on each of the nine areas in the Certification Standard. They are not added up into a score.
- Question and design. Can the approach answer the question asked and support the claims?
- Methods. Appropriate, and described well enough to evaluate?
- Data and materials. Identified and available where they apply?
- Analysis. Appropriate, with assumptions stated and checked?
- Results and reporting. Complete and consistent across text, tables and figures?
- Claims and conclusions. The ones the evidence supports?
- Verifiability. How far could the reviewer check the work from what was provided?
- Prior work and references. Do the key sources say what the manuscript says they say?
- Transparency. Funding, competing interests, AI use and registration stated where they apply?
How XSci peer certification works
Certification needs two answers, both yes: no major error that makes the central claims wrong, unsupported or impossible to evaluate; and fit for the target, a genuine prospect of publication in the target journals after ordinary revision.
Certification is not journal acceptance, a promise of publication, or an endorsement by the target journals. If the manuscript is not certified, you still receive the full report and the reasons.
Independent reviewers
Reviewers must declare competing interests, and disqualifying relationships rule them out. Their payment does not depend on the verdict, and XSci never directs a conclusion. Reviews are single-blind: the reviewer's identity is not disclosed.
Fees, disclosure and your rights
- One fee per round. The same whatever the decision. It pays for an assessment, not a certification. Current prices are on the submission page.
- Public or private report. On a published preprint the public price is lower, and that report is published automatically 48 hours after it is released to you. Without publishing, the report is private, and you pay the difference between the public and private price.
- One response, then revise. To have revised work assessed, post the updated version and request a new assessment.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to publish my manuscript on XSci first?
No. The assessment is the same either way, but certification can only be conferred on a preprint posted on XSci.
Is it the same as journal peer review?
No. It is separate from any journal's editorial process and does not mean a journal has accepted the work.
Does paying guarantee certification?
No. The fee covers an independent assessment; certification requires the work to meet the standard.
How is it different from AI review?
AI review is machine-generated feedback and never certifies. Expert review is a researcher's judgement against your target journals. Explore AI Paper Review
Find out if your paper is ready for your target journals.
One expert in your field, judged against the journals you are aiming at, with a written report whatever the decision.